Showing posts with label TM Krishna. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TM Krishna. Show all posts

Sunday, January 22, 2017

What Poromboke can learn from Jallikattu?

Two campaigns launched a few days apart; one riding on arts and another on culture both unfolding along the shores Bay of Bengal in Chennai. The first campaign had much needed star cast brew the perfect storm, while second campaign without a star cast was expected to fizzle out. When launched, the first one remained a storm in a tea cup, while the second one turned viral garnering state-wide support across age-groups, religion and gender. As a Marketing Communications professional, I decided to understand the similarities, differences and why one of them had larger reach and desired impact.

Music and Activism
The first campaign was jointly launched by Nithyanand Jayaram and TM Krishna. TM Krishna is a leading Carnatic Vocalist is the recent recipient of the prestigious Magsaysay Award, often considered Asia's Nobel Prize for "social inclusiveness in culture". He is the second musician to win this coveted award after a gap for four decades. While Nithyanand Jayaram, a writer and researcher based in Chennai investigates and reports on corporate abuses of environment and human rights, and is part of an anti-corporate collective called Vettiver Koottamaippu (Collective).

What happens when music and activism join hands? Well, a melodious song Poromboke is born to save the Ennore Creek and the Kosasthalaiyar river. The song tuned in medley of ragas with a dash of satire highlights the rampant development and encroachment of Poramboke lands making it a public responsibility to reclaim encroached lands.



Culture and Activism
Two days after Pongal festival, a handful of students gathered at Marina Beach demanding the ban on Jalkikattu, a traditional bull taming festival in rural Tamil Nadu be revoked permanently. Due to animal cruelty, PETA had reached out to Supreme Court of India, which banned this activity in May 2014.

Without a leader, this campaign seeking to revoke the ban was ignored by politicians in both state at center, who made it a part of their poll promise failed to fulfill when voted to power. When students organized themselves demanding the ban to be lifted, crowd started to swell and the campaign eventually turned into a state-wide protest. People across gender, age-group and religion joined hands to reinstate the cultural tradition of Tamils.

Staying relevant is Success
Both Music and culture are inseparable and firmly rooted in history and tradition. Nevertheless, both need mass appeal and relevance for its survival. Staying relevant to the current needs of the society and willingness to amend and upgrade ensures long-term success.This probably explains why Carnatic Music has a dwindling appeal and why some cruel traditions like sati have vanished.

When I came across TMK's tweet a few hours after his video launch, I watched it and honestly tweeted that their efforts would fail to reach larger audience as a result of poor segmentation. Though the messaging in the song to save Ennore Creek and raise awareness around encroachment is noble, clear and relevant, but using Carnatic Music as a medium was a poor choice. While TM Krishna is still waging a war to make Carnatic Music more inclusive and accessible to all sections of the society, using it to create awareness among the larger sections of the society is too soon and shortsighted - a poor marketing strategy. As a result, the shock value from this video failed to gather adequate steam, become viral and morph into a protest. As usual, the Brahmin population appreciated the musical aspects of the song and moved on to the next venue for the next tukkada.

What I admire the most
On the other hand, Jallikattu campaigners (read as students) with no one leader, used popular faces like RJ Balaji, Lawrence Raghava to tear into bureaucrats, politicians, PETA, AWB and Supreme Court of India. They brilliantly turned the ban on Jallikattu as an attack on Tamil identity and tapped into their ire and helplessness to recruit Tamils for the cause. Urbanites who are often accused by rural for swaying away from tradition were leading the protest. Those who didn't have a clue about Jallikattu and bulls were now ambassadors. Unbelievable, huh?

Honestly, I couldn't bear my educated colleagues arguing how Jallikattu is the only way save 37 varieties of bulls from becoming extinct, as a way to fight against increasing cancer from consuming A1 type milk and the only way to save culture and tradition without addressing their poor behavior and lifestyle choices. Isn't this shear stupidity?

Dwarfing differences
Carnatic Music is very much a part of our tradition and culture, but how we use it to fight a larger cause must be intelligently crafted and executed. In spite of addressing a common problem that marooned Chennai city in 2015 December, they picked the wrong target audience and wrong medium to deliver the message that resulted in only 108,00 views on You Tube.

Jallikattu campaigners picked an issue irrelevant to urbanites, yet made them rally for a rural cause, turned the city into and epicenter of protest. To engage with millennials they churned out memes and witty limericks and shrewdly kept politicians and film fraternity away, who could steal their show and weaken their protest. By acting peacefully and responsibly on the ground they also won the appreciation of police and admiration of fellow Indians.

Changing the words in the first Charanam of the Poromboke song... Jallikattu pona pinne kathutathu yenna...? It is time for crusaders like TM Krishna and Nithyanand Jayaram to join these protest to understand why it succeeds and take a leaf or two to make their future campaigns fail-proof and successful.

Thursday, December 17, 2015

Goodbye Sudha, Welcome Sangeetha!

Many years ago the famous Carnatic music critic Subuddu was asked whose music would he would listen to if he were ever stranded in an Island. His candid answer to the question was Smt. Sudha Ragunathan. Though I'm not comparing myself with Subuddu, but if I were asked a similar question tweaking to today's situation ( For ex: Nov 23, 2015 traffic snarl) without a wink I would say Sangeetha Swaminathan. 

I have never heard Sangeetha live, but listening to her music on my iPad, Desi Radio app, I felt she came across as a sincere performer with depth, maturity and more importantly she had brilliantly internalized her guru's style, Smt. Sudha Raghunathan. And for those of you who are missing Sudha's concerts this Markazhi, cancelled due to medical issues, you can definitely bank on Sangeetha to fill that void. Sangeetha sounds like Sudha's replica from 20 years ago, when the entire MLV school of music was left on her shoulders to be carried forward.

Finally, I heard Sangeetha live at Charsur's Arts Foundation, where she deftly and diligently handled 4 of 72 melakartas bringing out unheard compositions and educating listeners. As I was getting ready for her concert, a septuagenarian and mother of a popular musician dissuaded me from going there. Her line of defense was that concerts focusing only on the 72 melakartas can be a tedious listening experience. Nevertheless, I made it!

From the go would not be the right usage for a Carnatic music concert, so let's say from the strum of the tanpura shruthi, Sangeetha breath was brimming with music. She began the evening with a Chelini Kori varnam in Gowlai (melakarta # ) that set the mood and also raised the expectations of audience. She beautifully presented Gaanamutham, a composition of Kotieshwara Iyer in Salagam (melakarta #37 ). It would not be a exaggeration if I said Sangeetha's music is Gaananutham. 

Taking up rarely heard melakarta ragas for enunciation is not easy task for the artist since they will have to strike balance between educating and entertaining listeners. Sangeetha sketched a beautiful outline of Devakriya raga aka Suddha Saveri before taking up the rarely heard Sandhya Devim Saavithri, a composition of Dikshithar. The long and not so easily pronounceable Sanskrit phrases in the song set to Devakriya raga made the nereval exercise at Guptatara marga as difficult as the ascend to K2. This ascend not only needs skill, maturity but also blessings of the lord of the mountain, namely, the composer. Sangeetha's music seems to have that in abundance.

While listeners were mentally gasping, Sangeetha took up Thavar Izhaipadhu Yen Iyalpandro in Ragavardhini (melakarta #32) with humility and sincerity. Kalpanaswarams at Devar Sirai Meeta was captivating and proved her musical lineage. 

Just as I was thinking how could a concert be complete without Thyagaraja's composition, Sangeetha sketched a crisp Bilhari followed by Intakann aanandamemi o Rama making us feel Intakaan aanandamemi o Sangeetha! 

With cricket matches and Carnatic concerts shrinking to shorter formats, musicians and players rarely get opportunity to exhibit their talent and showmanship. Despite having only 45 minutes at her disposal, Sangeetha essayed Dharmavathi (melakarta # 59) displaying length and breadth of the raga and without repetition of the phrases during execution of Thanam and Pallavi. 

The Pallavi - Krishnam Mukundam Bhagavantham Hridi Bhajami, Brindavana Sthambam Sukumaaram was both presented in Darmavathi and Maand, which was followed up with kalpanaswarams in Dharmavathi, Sahana, Nagaswarali, Maand showcasing the mastery of her parampara in manodharma sangeetham. 

While I left the concert humming Sangeetha's concluding Hamir Kalyani thillana, I was asking myself, why do the current crop of musicians like Sudha, Sanjay, TM Krishna, etc. despite having successful students don't use them as vocal support? Is the usage vocal supports considered demeaning to the stature of the musician? Are vocal supports categorized alongside hearing aids, reading glasses, and walking sticks? But didn't seem to be the case with Sudha, who accompanied her guru for many years before becoming a torch bearer of MLV baani. Or is it simply because their bloated egos and insecurity that still prefer thaniavarthanam? It takes a lot of thinking and magnanimity to write a will and appoint their torch bearers just as it takes a lot of honesty to comes to terms with what one doesn't know. So, don't refrain from finding out what you don't know from attending series like the ongoing one on Melakarta.

All said and done, Sangeetha should not be seen as substitute for Sudha, but as an able torch bearer for the GNB, MLV and Sudha parampara. Despite her vidwat, Sangeetha hasn't been duly recognized with awards or titles by the Sabhas that mushroom by the dozen every Markazhi in the city. But that doesn't to have any bearing on her music. Is it because she is a resident of California and not part of these frogs that fight and croak in Mylapore wells? If Subuddu was around, he would have definitely said, "Good bye Sudha, Welcome Sangeetha!"

Saturday, January 31, 2009

Markazhi Ragam – A carnatic sound and light show

It would not be an exaggeration if I call the movie Markazhi Ragam a Carnatic Sound and Light show. The auditorium was dark; lights appeared and disappeared at appropriate time and to evoke the mood of the song, stage décor and artist costume kept changing as the artist moved on from one rage to another and one composer to another and one deity to another. The dais was free from clutter (are we in Singapore) no flask or Bisleri bottles, no electronic sruthi box to hide notebooks. I could not see any kancheevarams, jasmine flowers, glass bangles, shawls or kurtas, (except for the artists) but instead it was jeans, salwar, skirts, high heals, and expensive perfume fragrance. Does it sound uncarnatic? Are we pushing the boundaries of music, art and culture? or should we call this redifining the boundaries? Is this movie for serious carnatic aficionados or an effort to glamorize carnatic music or bring out the physics of carnatic music? Why can it be all of the three?

You can have diffused lighting, expensive Bose speakers, but none other than Mayamalavagowlai can create the carnatic concert mood and tether all audience in the concert hall. Jayashree in her typically meditative style sang Ponnaiya Pillai’s (Tanjore Quartret) Mayathirthaswaroopini. The camera was busy framing the vocalist, her mohana maalai and stone studded pendent, and exposing the fabric in her expensive silk draped over the piped blouse. Then the camera stood over the violinist shoulder to capture the dynamics between the violinist and the vocalist and finally it decided to settle with Jayashree as she kept pouring the swaras for this lilting composition. The song ended with the Mudhra "Guruguha Swamiku Ne dasu daini" in the Samasti Charanam.

The screen turned dark and blank like the starless and moonless night and suddenly the new dawn broke and Jayashree had taken us to Nagapattinam. One could hear the boundaries of Neelambari sketched with atmost devotion, mastery and sincerity and slowly unfolding Muthuswamy Dikshithar’s Amba Neelayathakshi. Images from 3 cameras were beamed on the screen captured the breaking sweat beads on the percussionist’s forehead and the mike popping out from her sternum.

Jayashree sat on the stage like a fully bloomed lotus with a 1000 petals adorning the pond. Her right hand was busy holding the baby and moving it back and forth while her heart was doing the talam count. It would not be an exaggeration if I said Jayashree became a mother to the mother goddess while rendering this kriti.

Every raga is a fresh canvas on which artists paint their imagination and creativity. The audience was busy swaying their heads soaked in the raga, while some were busy trying to guess the krithi. One could hear enthralling Reethigowlai on the horizon against Jayashree’s silhouette. Subburaya Shastri’s Janani Ninnuvina, the famous beautiful madhyama kaala krithi in Reethigowla raga was presented. Nereval at Saraseeruha lochani Suvaasini Taamasamu Seyakane Brovumu was delectable and effusing with surrender and bakthi. The camera zoomed in on her face while the lights made the diamonds on her nose dazzle (reminded me of Devi Kanyakumari.) while she sang the krithi with poise and perfection. For some music is a hobby, but for Jayashree music was definitely tapasya. There was no change in timbre of tambura, and at an unexpected moment clad in a red kurta and dazzling kadukkan TM Krishna appeared on the horizon and completed the kriti after the taniavarthanam. It was indeed a nice way to introduce him in the concert movie!

I don’t know if it was it Michelangelo stroke, Picasso’s brush or Midas touch, but all of it seemed to be present in TM Krishna’s elaboration of Behag. The raga engulfed the auditorium, while both vocalist and violinist were on a motivating journey to get each other beyond the imagination boundaries of absent rasikas. TMK rendered Swati Tirunaal’s Saramaina Maatalanda chalu chalu ra Javali in Telugu.

Be it reflections of the string, fabric of the bow, craters on the Mridhangam, or viboothi, kumkum on the artist forehead, cuticles on his nails, the camera captured the stage dynamics real and raw without any deception or manipulation. Swaying his arms, and picking up the swaras and sahityam with his right in enthusiasm TMK was playing a perfect volley with the violinist. The eyes of the violinist RK Shriramkumar kept watching the vocalist’s lips and transmitting them back on the strings. While the Mridhangist Arun Prakash was kept his ears open to play apt theermanans for the sangathis rendered by the vocalist.

Could there be a concert without a Thyagaraja krithi? May be Thyagaraja didn’t want Seetha to feel insecure and possessive and that is why he addressed Rama as Seethapathi in the Kamas kriti?

There was no premium pricing for this concert and a front row or back row really didn’t matter and everyone got to see everything clear, candid and without any compromise. May be that was the reason why Arun Prakash looked very conscious, while the TMK sishya on the tampura was joyous all the time, while the French sishya was always hiding behind the Tampura?

Can there be a Markazhi without RTP? TMK elaborated the Subha pantuvarali and presented a short thanam and pallavi “Brahmai vaha kila satguru kripa” in Sama, Kamas and Subha Pantuvarali. It was not just TMK who had less interaction with the Mridhangist, but the cameras too stayed away from this artist. Why this partiality?

If she was a calm ocean, he was a rumbling volcano. Both of them had their distinct and captivating styles. TMK remained muted while Jayashree rendered Kararavindhena Mukharavindham from Balamukundashtakam in Ragamalika in her impeccable meditative style with only tampura sruthi on the background. TMK came right back into the frame to render Purundaradasar’s Jagodhodharana in Kapi.

The sound and light show ended with a piece in raga Yamuna Kalyani. This brought all artist and instruments together – a perfect ensemble and spirit of unity. Jayashree and TMK took turns to render Vandemaataram in Yamuna Kalyani, Kapi and Sindu Bairavi.

Everything seemed the same at the end of this concert on reel. A portion of the crowd that walked in sipping coke and carrying a tub of caramel popcorn seemed happy, contented and musically satisfied at the end. I found them chewing the same cud discussing on camera angles, artist costumes, jewellery with fervor and enthusiasm. A few musical die-hards were busy discussing real music on the reel – ragas, swaras, composers, physics of sound and music.


http://www.margazhiraagam.com/

Friday, November 21, 2008

Suswara Samyuta by TM Krishna & Bombay Jayashri


She was dressed in an olive green saree (Maanthulir) - tender, fresh and full of life just like her music and he was wearing a deep red kurta (Molahapazham) striking, rich, fiery and aggressive. Should we just listen to the music or interpret their singing style from their attire? What would be the outcome when such distinctly different styles of music confluence?

The ambience was energetic and the tampura drones that engulfed the house full auditorium only raised their curiosity levels and made them levitate to find out what is on the other side of the curtain. Finally when the curtains went up so did their eyebrows. TM Krishna and Bombay Jayashri adorned the dais with calm and majesty. They came from two different schools of Music one trained by Sangeetha Pithamaha Semmangudi Srinivasa Iyer and other molded by the violin Maestro Lalgudi Jayaraman. Can two different and distinct schools of music blend together and bring the divine unison without compromising on individual identity, style and creative freedom?

To add to this vocal fanfare we had renowned percussionist and non-percussionist – RK Shriramkumar who accompanied doyens like Semmangudi mama and MS amma on the violin, Ghatam Karthik and Arun Prakash on the mridangam, both distinctly accomplished and associated with music for more than two and half decades. In totality there was more than 125 years of musical experience on the dias – it was undoubtedly a confluence of jambavans.

The army of 4 tampuras strummed to bring the two souls to the same sruthi – musically and metaphysically. Jayashree started with Omkara Pancharasukhi, a stuthi on Parvathi and Krishna soon joined her in perfect sruthi and together they rendered the piece in Mayamalavagowlai, Sahana, Kalyani, Reethigowlai and the and Todi. Muthuswamy Dikshithar’s Rave Himagiri in Todi followed the stuthi in an unhurried pace packed with sowkyam. Jayashree’s voice carried the innate softness, and was laden with bakthi. It was as mild as a morning breeze, while TM Krishna was brisk, energizing and loaded with technicalities and emotions.

Saalakalla in Aarabhi was delivered with effervescence, spirit and swara. It had shades of brilliance from both their paatanthiram. Remember it is never easy for male and female singer to comfortably sing at a mutually convenient sruthi and that too from 2 different schools of music. Though TMK did not sing at his usual pitch, but his output didn’t suffer in terms of quality or sruthi.

While the audience was lost in the musical heaven the illumination on the dais quickly changed to reflect the mood of the raga and the composition. The stage turned saffron to go with the bakthi flavor in the krithi Nadhaloludai in Kalyanavasantham. When did Carnatic music become so sensory?

TMK showed maturity in rendering kritis loaded with such bhava and bakthi with atmost devotion and perfection. When one did the sanchara at the higher octave, the other would get into the lower octave without distracting the other.

The next piece titled Mahitha Bharatham paid tribute to our land, our thought and our philosophy. Violinist RK Shriramkumar must be given a big hand for picking up apt verses from Tagore, Barathi, Poonthanam, etc. in different languages to salute India and our motherland. This piece made the concert a Jugalbandhi. Diffused white, green and saffron lighting on the dais accentuated the sense of patriotism.

Shubhadayaka mahitha Bharatham Vande mathram – Shankarabharanam – Sanskrit

Hazaron khahishen aisi ki har khasish pe dam nikle – Shubapantuvarali - Urdu
Accham illai accham illai accham enbadillaye – Kambodhi – Tamil
Purona Shei diner kotha bhulbi ki re hai, o shei – Ananda Bairavi– Bengali
Chirunavvulu shirulu kanuchupulo karuna – Reetigowlai – Telugu
Kandu Kandann Irikkum janangale – Sivaranjani – Malayalam
Maati Kahe kumbhar ko tu kya rondhe mohe – Sindhubairavi – Hindi

The 6 language piece was presented in the typical ragam, thanam and pallavi style with enough room for swara exercise and thani avarthanam. The choice of the lines and ragas brought out the mightiness and diversity of our motherland and finally concluded with the famous Vande Maatram piece.

The last 15 minutes of the concert was packed with some lighter Hindustani ragas. Sri Ramachandra Kripalo in Behag, Sarvam Bhramamayam in Durbari Kanada. The double thillana rendition in Kamas was a highlight. Jayshri had taken Lalgudi’s composition and Krishna had taken a similar one from his school and they rendered them separately and in the end they came to together like strands of DNA.

The evening was very different in every respect – singers from different schools in Carnatic music coming together yet maintaining their individual identity and creativity. The stage décor added to the wow factor, the crowd turned disciplined and switched off their microwaves and washing machines and stayed in their seats till the curtain came down. This was the first time in the Carnatic Music history that music was ever made so sensory and stimulating. May be it is birth of a new dawn in the South Indian classical music?